Psychedelic mushrooms are becoming more and more popular by the day. Yet, unlike weed, gaining access to them isn’t such a straightforward process.
The reason for this is that the main active compound in psychedelic mushrooms, psilocybin, is illegal in most of the world. And sure, while research on them is being done, the reality is that legalization is still years away.
This makes trying to get legal and effective magic mushroom gummies a challenge. And that’s if you’re not getting scammed, which is an unfortunate but common occurrence in this unregulated market.
However, psilocybin isn’t the be-all-end-all of magic mushrooms, and there’s an exciting alternative that’s completely legal in the United States.
Amanita muscaria doesn’t contain any psilocybin. Instead, it contains a compound called muscimol, which produces unique psychoactive effects when consumed. The best part? It's legal and can be bought easily and cheaply online.
Top 6 Best Magic Mushroom Gummies You Can Legally Buy in 2024
So, now that we know there’s a way to order shrooms online, what options are available?
Here’s the shortlist of the best legal shroom vendors on the market right now:
- Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies — Amanita, THC, blue lotus, dream herb, 5HTP, ashwagandha, & vitamin B6.
- Royal Amanita Mushroom Gummies — Muscimol, THC, 5HTP, calea, lotus flower, & withania.
- Elevate Mushroom Gummies — Simple muscimol.
- Koi MusciMind Gummies — Low-dose muscimol.
- Cosmyic HHC + Amanita Gummies — HHC and muscimol.
- Elyxr Amanita Muscaria Gummies — Simple muscimol.
Let's take a deeper look at each of these products, what makes them so great, and how they compare against each other.
1. Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies [TOP PICK 2024]
The Area 52 Magic Pluto Gummies are among the few lab-tested, safe, and wild-grown offerings in the legal magic mushroom space. The team over at Area 52 is so confident of their gummies that they're offering a 30-day no-questions-asked return policy. They're also completely open about their process and formulation (more on this later).
While these gummies are primarily made using the muscimol found in Amanita muscaria, they also contain a mix of vitamins, amino acids, hemp extract, and various other psychoactive botanicals.
Users will immediately notice how the Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies' quality is unmatched by market alternatives. The expert psychonauts over at Area 52 make sure to deliver a product they want to use themselves and refuse to settle for anything that could be considered low-quality or disappointing.
Advantages of Area 52’s Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies:
- |+| One of the strongest muscimol gummies on the market.
- |+| Formulated with 8 synergistic botanicals and vitamins.
- |+| Rock-solid money-back guarantee on all orders.
- |+| Free shipping on select orders.
- |+| Formula approved by master herbalist and psychedelics expert.
2. Royal Amanita Mushroom Gummies [RUNNER UP]
These Amanita Muscaria mushroom gummies are some of the most potent you’ll find at the sub-fifty dollar price point. Most of the options in the cheaper range contain what can only be considered microdoses (non-psychoactive doses). These gummies are made with an impressive 10 mg pure muscimol and an additional 10 mg THC — all completely legal in the United States.
Royal has been making cannabis products for years and has earned itself a stellar reputation. Most companies offering magic mushroom products today have only been around for a few months. Royal has been serving customers since 2017.
They’re one of the few brands in the space that practice what they preach — offering exceptionally high-quality and consistent products, all backed by independent lab testing.
These gummies are an excellent option if you want to try legal shroom gummies that hit your mind hard but not your wallet.
Advantages of Royal’s Amanita Mushroom Gummies:
- [+] Excellent value for the money.
- [+] Made with a variety of synergistic ingredients.
- [+] 30-day money-back guarantee on all orders.
- [+] World-class customer service team.
- [+] Free shipping to all US customers.
3. Elevate Mushroom Gummies [Best Low-Dose Mushroom Gummies]
The Elevate Mushroom Gummies are the second best choice after the Magic Pluto gummies. Elevate has been on the market for a fair number of years now and has an extensive catalog of products under its belt — so it isn’t all that surprising to see it try its hand at a magic mushroom alternative.
While the Elevate gummies are a solid offering, the potency of each gummy is half that of Area 52’s. Being a purely Amanita-based product also makes it fall short due to the lack of ingredients balancing or enhancing the formula.
Advantages & Disadvantages of the Elevate Mushroom Gummies:
- [+] No third-party testing available.
- [+] Decent price point for people on a strict budget.
- [–] Relatively low potency product with just 5 mg muscimol.
- [–] Lacks the added benefits of synergistic botanicals and vitamins.
4. Koi MusciMind Gummies
Koi's new formula aims to deliver an otherworldly experience by combining three natural ingredients: muscimol, lion's mane, and hostilis bark. The result is a relaxed trip that will gently fade into some of the most vivid dreams you'll ever encounter.
The combined power of the two mushrooms and the hostilis bark may seem like a bit much for beginners, so the team at Koi opted for low-potency gummies. While these may not be as powerful as the ones from Area 52, they are a great option for microdosing.
Advantages & Disadvantages of the Koi MusciMind Gummies:
- [+] Affordable pricing.
- [+] Stringent lab testing.
- [–] May lack potency for more experienced users.
- [–] Users may have to take a lot of gummies for intense experiences.
5. Cosmyic HHC + Amanita Gummies
The Cosmyic HHC + Amanita Gummies offer more of a classic experience compared to other muscimol or psilocybin gummies. These gummies lean more towards the side of a weed high than a proper trip or exotic dreamlike effects, so do keep that in mind.
We recommend these for people who want to unwind after a long day of work or chill out after a stressful week. But if you're looking for a more "pure" Amanita trip, the Cosmyic gummies probably won't cut it.
Advantages & Disadvantages of the Cosmyic HHC + Amanita Gummies:
- [+] Great synergy between muscimol and HHC.
- [+] Affordable pricing.
- [–] HHC adds limitations on which states the company can ship to.
- [–] No lab testing available.
6. Elyxr Amanita Muscaria Mushroom Gummies
The Elyxr Gummies have a few advantages over others on this list: mainly, the "party pack"-sized format and the fact that they contain wild-harvested amanita. However, the muscimol concentration is rather low, coming in at a very modest 1.7 mg per gummy.
Still, these may be useful for people looking to microdose or for a gentle introduction to the Amanita world. Due to the lack of extra ingredients, the potency of the trip can be… a bit underwhelming. And luckily, the price reflects that.
Advantages & Disadvantages of the Elyxr Amanita Muscaria Mushroom Gummies:
- [+] Lots of flavors to choose from.
- [+] Very affordable pricing.
- [+] Low muscimol concentration.
- [–] No synergizing ingredients.
Why Some Mushroom Gummies Are Much Stronger Than Others
All the best magic mushroom gummies contain more than just one simple ingredient. Synergy refers to the idea that multiple ingredients that work well together produce effects that are more than the sum of their parts.
Let's say one ingredient is equal to +1 the effect. If we have three non-synergistic ingredients, the effects will be 1+1+1=3.
If the formula is skillfully crafted to leverage the effects of each ingredient perfectly, the result will be closer to 1+1+1=10. See how the total potency of effects is much stronger with synergy?
Let’s look at the Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom gummies as an example of excellent synergy in a magic mushroom gummy.
In this formula, the active Amanita muscaria extract serves as the foundation, but it's the other ingredients that bring everything together and make the gummies act much stronger.
Other Psychoactive Constituents
On top of Amanita, Area 52 adds full-spectrum hemp extract, which is a potent mixture of CBD, CBG, CBN, CBC, and roughly 15 mg of THC. These compounds boost the psychoactive profile of amanita through completely separate mechanisms. The result is that both the amanita and the muscimol have a much stronger psychoactive effect.
Dream-Enhancers
Dream Herb and Ashwagandha are two herbs that were carefully chosen due to their dream-inducing effects. Other cultures have used these two for hundreds if not thousands of years already.
In addition to them, the Blue Lotus Flower (Nymphaea caerulea) was added as well. It’s a potent flower that the ancient Egyptians used in their ceremonies, and nowadays, it’s used to induce lucid dreaming.
The addition of plants that make you manifest powerful dreams and give you the ability to control them allows you to make the most out of your muscimol-induced dreams.
Neurotransmitter Supportive
The Magic Pluto Gummies also contains L-Theanine and 5-HTP, which can clear your mind, enhance focus, and reduce grogginess. They'll keep you from feeling exhausted, a common side effect caused by other products.
Vitamin B6 rounds off the ingredient list. Yes, good old vitamin B6 is added to the mix to keep the amino acids in check and help your immune system process the new substances in the body.
The Magic Pluto Gummies are all about enhancing your cognitive functions, so it just makes sense to add a vitamin that improves your brain’s health.
How to Take Magic Mushroom Gummies
A common mistake experienced and inexperienced users make is taking more than they can handle. If this is your first time using gummies, start with one gummy. Give it some time to kick in, and do not take more than two daily gummies.
The same applies if you’ve already had other gummies before. Magic mushroom gummies are not meant to be eaten like candy. Use them responsibly and with care.
The effects will manifest over the course of an hour. They start slow and subtly ramp up until they peak at around two or three hours. Overall, you can expect a journey that lasts between four and six hours.
Be patient and ensure you have no other responsibilities that could get in the way. If you have a friend who could help keep an eye on you during your first time using it, even better.
What Effects Should I Expect from Magic Mushroom Gummies?
The effects of Amanita muscaria’s muscimol and the added mixture of exotic ingredients revolve around lucidity, perception, and dreams.
While awake, you will feel the world around you and the things surrounding you come into focus while seeming distant and ethereal.
Your senses may get distorted to the point where things like size or shape mix with each other or take on new forms. Time and space will bend, making a few minutes feel like several hours or making hours pass by in what feels like seconds.
If you fall asleep, the real effects begin as your mind transcends dream states of an otherworldly nature.
However, keep in mind that the ingredients at play here are what many ancient cultures used for sacred rituals or to communicate with other realms. What worked for them could very well work for you, too!
Pros & Cons of Buying Magic Mushroom Gummies Online
One of the biggest pros of buying shrooms online is convenience. Nothing beats buying gummies or tinctures and having them delivered to your house in a matter of days.
In the case of the Area 52 Magic Pluto Gummies, standard shipping is free, with priority shipping as an option as well.
Another pro is simply not having to deal with unreliable shops or individual sellers. Area 52 and similar shops offer a large variety of gummies and tinctures, while local stores will be limited to whatever is available in their area.
Dealing with your average street vendor can also be a bit of a nuisance, as they might be busy, out of the city, or often out of stock.
Safety is also something to consider, as even reputable companies might fall into the trap of mixing more powerful but untested components into their products. Experienced users know what it is like to try something unexpectedly potent or go overboard with a dose only to regret it for the rest of the day.
As always, if you’re buying online, tread carefully. Check reviews and ingredient lists—even the price can be a good tell. If it seems too good to be true, then it often is!
Amanita Muscaria: A Closer Look
Amanita muscaria, better known as the Fly Agaric, is a mushroom growing in the northern hemisphere. You can find it in North America, Northern Europe, and many Asian countries.
They grow in woods and meadows, usually on damp soil rich with humus and other plant remains. This is why it's not uncommon to find them all over dead or decaying trees or even grassy, moist areas and exposed to the sun.
This mushroom wasn’t chosen at random—there’s a long history of shamanic rituals that involve using Amanita muscaria to induce a trance-like state.
The legend goes that the shrooms would open a portal to the spiritual world, granting the users visions and insights and even making them feel like they were flying.
However, as impressive as these experiences can be, you should be careful around these and any other mushrooms you might find in the wild.
Amanita muscaria can be poisonous if eaten raw or handled without care due to its components, and it can lead to some nasty side effects like nausea, vomiting, agitation, etc.
This is why it’s better to simply let the professionals handle it. Most of the dangerous aspects of these mushrooms are weeded out through lab testing and quality control procedures, which ensures they only keep what is useful and necessary.
Be careful when buying Amanita muscaria online. Only order from high-grade, authoritative, and trustworthy vendors.
Which Magic Mushrooms Are Legal?
There are hundreds of psychedelic mushrooms out there, with new variants or strains being developed and discovered every year.
The problem is that they contain psilocybin, so regardless of how different their chemical makeup or appearance might be from each other, they’re all forbidden by law.
You might find products that advertise themselves as “psychedelic gummies” that don’t contain psilocybin and think you’ve struck gold. Sadly, some psychedelic edibles use a synthetic analog to psilocybin called 4-AcO-DMT.
4-AcO-DMT is only legal for research purposes, so selling it is out of the question. Also, it's unclear how it could react to other common ingredients in mushroom gummies.
Of course, that hasn’t stopped sketchy sellers from trying to add 4-AcO-DMT or other low-quality synthetic psychoactive compounds to their mixes without disclosing it.
You may also find vendors that try to circumvent the law by selling magic mushroom spores. While selling these spores is technically legal, growing magic mushrooms isn’t. You could get in deep trouble if law enforcement were to find your secret stash.
These reasons make Amanita muscaria gummies the best legal alternative out there. Since they’re fully legal, there’s no need to resort to gray areas or buy potentially harmful synthetic alternatives.
Frequently Asked Questions About Using Shrooms
Here are some of the most common questions asked about magic mushrooms online.
1. Will magic mushrooms make me fail a drug test?
This will depend entirely on the type of test. For example, urine tests will look for hard drugs but often overlook psilocybin or other components of magic mushrooms.
A more thorough and specialized test, such as a hallucinogen test, will catch traces of peyote, mescaline, LSD, and psilocybin mushrooms.
This is another point in favor of muscimol-based products. Since they're legal, there's no reason to look for them. Just be careful of who you purchase your shrooms from, as some companies use illegal alternatives to psilocybin, such as 4-AcO-DMT, which will register on drug tests.
2. What are the risks of growing magic mushrooms at home?
Home cultivation of magic mushrooms is relatively simple, and many excellent guides are available online. However, this practice is just as illegal as the mushrooms themselves. While you can purchase spores legally because they don't contain any active psilocybin, you'll be breaking the law as soon as the spores germinate.
3. How long do magic mushrooms stay in my system?
On average, mushrooms will stay in a person's system for 24 hours, give or take. It depends on many factors such as age, weight, metabolism, dose, how much you eat before using them, what type of mushroom, whether it is dry or fresh, etc…
References
- Vitamin B6 - Health Professional Fact Sheet. (2023, June 16). NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Retrieved January 18, 2024, from https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminB6-HealthProfessional/
- Lowe, G. (n.d.). Mind And Spirit - Fly Agaric. USDA Forest Service. Retrieved January 19, 2024, from https://www.fs.usda.gov/wildflowers/ethnobotany/Mind_and_Spirit/flyagaric.shtml
- Rampolli, F. I., Kamler, P., Carnevale Carlino, C., & Bedussi, F. (2021). The Deceptive Mushroom: Accidental Amanita muscaria Poisoning. European journal of case reports in internal medicine, 8(3), 002212. https://doi.org/10.12890/2021_002212
- Lott, J. P., Marlowe, D. B., & Forman, R. F. (2009). Availability of websites offering to sell psilocybin spores and psilocybin. Journal of psychoactive drugs, 41(3), 305–307. https://doi.org/10.1080/02791072.2009.10400541